| Item | Description | Background Information | Decision |
| | APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE | APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE
There were no apologies for absence. | |
| 22/20 | DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST | DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST
Councillor Elliman informed the Committee that he was ward Councillor for Applications 2021/0328/FUL and 2021/0329/LBW and had previously spoken to one of the owners of the property.
Councillor Lohan informed the Committee that he knew the person speaking in support of Application 2021/0753/OUT. | |
| 22/21 | MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 14 MARCH, 2022 | MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 14 MARCH, 2022
The Minutes of the Meeting held on 14 March, 2022 were submitted for confirmation.
Minutes | RESOLVED - That the Minutes of the Meeting held on 14 March, 2022 be confirmed as a correct record. |
| 22/22 | PLANNING APPLICATION REFERENCE: 2021/0704/RES RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOLLOWING OUTLINE APPLICATION 2020/0182/OUT (OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF UP TO 200 DWELLINGS WITH ALL MATTERS RESERVED WITH THE EXCEPTION OF ACCESS) - FOR 200 DWELLINGS, PUBLIC OPEN SPACE, LANDSCAPING AND ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE FOLLOWING APPROVAL OF OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION 2020/0182/OUT FOR UPTO 200 DWELLINGS - LAND AT THREE THORN HOLLOW FARM, BLIDWORTH LANE, RAINWORTH | PLANNING APPLICATION REFERENCE: 2021/0704/RES RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOLLOWING OUTLINE APPLICATION 2020/0182/OUT (OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF UP TO 200 DWELLINGS WITH ALL MATTERS RESERVED WITH THE EXCEPTION OF ACCESS) - FOR 200 DWELLINGS, PUBLIC OPEN SPACE, LANDSCAPING AND ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE FOLLOWING APPROVAL OF OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION 2020/0182/OUT FOR UPTO 200 DWELLINGS - LAND AT THREE THORN HOLLOW FARM, BLIDWORTH LANE, RAINWORTH
The Committee considered a reserved matters application following Outline Application 2020/0182/OUT (outline planning application for the development of up to 200 dwellings with all matters reserved with the exception of access) - for 200 dwellings, public open space, landscaping and associated infrastructure following approval of outline planning application 2020/0182/OUT for up to 200 dwellings at Land At Three Thorn Hollow Farm, Blidworth Lane, Rainworth.
In accordance with the Committee's public speaking procedure the undermentioned spoke as indicated:
Steve Iberle (Objector)
Robert Galij (Applicant)
Councillor Smart (Ward Councillor)
The applicant raised the prospect of amending 2 of the plots within the proposed development to improve the relationship with existing neighbouring properties. Officers advised Members that details of any amendments would need to be submitted and neighbours notified of those proposed amendments before a decision could be made on any revised scheme.
Councillor Wright proposed and Councillor Hanstock seconded that the application be deferred pending an amended application.
Councillor Wright proposed and Councillor Hanstock seconded that the application be deferred pending an amended application.
The motion being put to the vote it was announced that the motion be carried by 10 votes for with 1 vote against and 0 abstentions.
Land at Three Thorn Hollow Farm, Blidworth Lane, Rainworth | RESOLVED - That the reserved matters application following Outline Application 2020/0182/OUT (outline planning application for the development of up to 200 dwellings with all matters reserved with the exception of access) - for 200 dwellings, public open space, landscaping and associated infrastructure following approval of outline planning application 2020/0182/OUT for up to 200 dwellings at Land At Three Thorn Hollow Farm, Blidworth Lane, Rainworth be deferred pending an amended application. |
| 22/23 | JOINT REPORT – (1) PLANNING APPLICATION REFERENCE: 2021/0328/FUL PARTIAL DEMOLITION, REBUILD, CONVERSION AND EXTENSION OF A GRADE II LISTED MILL TO CREATE A 70 BED NURSING HOME AND THE ERECTION OF 31 NO. PRIVATE RESIDENTIAL DWELLINGS WITHIN THE CURTILAGE TOGETHER WITH ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE ANCILLARY FACILITIES, ACCESS, PARKING AND OPEN SPACES. AND (2) PLANNING APPLICATION REFERENCE: 2021/0329/LBW LISTED BUILDING CONSENT FOR THE PARTIAL DEMOLITION, REBUILD CONVERSION AND EXTENSION OF A GRADE II LISTED MILL TO CREATE A 70 BED NURSING HOME - HERMITAGE MILL, HERMITAGE LANE, MANSFIELD | JOINT REPORT – (1) PLANNING APPLICATION REFERENCE: 2021/0328/FUL PARTIAL DEMOLITION, REBUILD, CONVERSION AND EXTENSION OF A GRADE II LISTED MILL TO CREATE A 70 BED NURSING HOME AND THE ERECTION OF 31 NO. PRIVATE RESIDENTIAL DWELLINGS WITHIN THE CURTILAGE TOGETHER WITH ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE ANCILLARY FACILITIES, ACCESS, PARKING AND OPEN SPACES. AND (2) PLANNING APPLICATION REFERENCE: 2021/0329/LBW LISTED BUILDING CONSENT FOR THE PARTIAL DEMOLITION, REBUILD CONVERSION AND EXTENSION OF A GRADE II LISTED MILL TO CREATE A 70 BED NURSING HOME - HERMITAGE MILL, HERMITAGE LANE, MANSFIELD
The Committee considered a joint application for partial demolition, rebuild, conversion and extension of a Grade ii Listed Mill to create a 70 bed nursing home and the erection of 31 No. private residential dwellings within the curtilage together with associated infrastructure ancillary facilities, access, parking and open spaces together with listed building consent for the partial demolition, rebuild conversion and extension of a grade ii listed Mill to create a 70 bed nursing home at Hermitage Mill, Hermitage Lane, Mansfield.
Since publication of the report a late item had been received from Historic England. Historic England had raised concerns about the plans not being sufficient to show how much of the remaining building would be repaired along with the lack of a structural survey. This information should be provided prior to determination. They advised that any reinstatement work should be based on sound conservation philosophy using appropriate traditional materials. The Planning Officer explained that planning conditions would be sufficient to address the reinstatement of the Mill.
Councillor Shields proposed and Councillor Lohan seconded that Application 2021/0328/FUL be granted planning permission with conditions as detailed in the report.
The motion being put to the vote it was announced that the motion be carried by 9 votes for with 2 votes against and 0 abstentions.
Councillor Wright proposed and Councillor Shields seconded that listed building consent be granted for Application 2021/0329/LBW.
The motion being put to the vote it was announced that the motion be carried by 10 votes for with 1 vote against and 0 abstentions.
Hermitage Mill, Hermitage Lane, Mansfield | RESOLVED - That joint application for partial demolition, rebuild, conversion and extension of a Grade ii Listed Mill to create a 70 bed nursing home and the erection of 31 No. private residential dwellings within the curtilage together with associated infrastructure ancillary facilities, access, parking and open spaces together with listed building consent for the partial demolition, rebuild conversion and extension of a grade ii listed Mill to create a 70 bed nursing home at Hermitage Mill, Hermitage Lane, Mansfield be granted planning permission with conditions as detailed in the report. |
| 22/24 | PLANNING APPLICATION REFERENCE: 2021/0753/OUT OUTLINE APPLICATION WITH SOME MATTERS RESERVED FOR 3 NO. TOWN HOUSES - LAND ADJACENT MANSFIELD MANOR HOTEL, WINDMILL LANE, MANSFIELD | PLANNING APPLICATION REFERENCE: 2021/0753/OUT OUTLINE APPLICATION WITH SOME MATTERS RESERVED FOR 3 NO. TOWN HOUSES - LAND ADJACENT MANSFIELD MANOR HOTEL, WINDMILL LANE, MANSFIELD
The Committee considered an outline application with some matters reserved for 3 no. town houses at Land adjacent Mansfield Manor Hotel, Windmill Lane, Mansfield, Nottinghamshire.
In accordance with the Committee's Public Speaking Procedure the under mentioned spoke as indicated:
Paul Andrews (Supporter)
Councillor Shields proposed and Councillor Wright seconded that the application be refused planning permission for reasons outlined in the report.
The motion being put to the vote it was announced that the motion be carried by 6 votes for with 5 votes against and 0 abstentions.
Land adjacent Mansfield Manor Hotel, Windmill Lane, Mansfield | RESOLVED - That the outline application with some matters reserved for 3 no. town houses at Land adjacent Mansfield Manor Hotel, Windmill Lane, Mansfield, Nottinghamshire be refused planning permission for reasons outlined in the report. |
| 22/25 | APPENDICES OF HUMAN RIGHTS ACT AND USE CLASSES | APPENDICES OF HUMAN RIGHTS ACT AND USE CLASSES
The Human Rights Act and Use Classes were submitted for information.
Appendices 1 and 2 | RESOLVED - Noted. |
| 22/26 | APPEAL DECISIONS 26th March 2022 – 21st April 2022 | APPEAL DECISIONS 26th March 2022 – 21st April 2022
The Committee noted that there had been no Appeal Decisions received during the period 26 March, 2022 to 21 April, 2022.
Appeal decisions 26-03-2022 to 21-04-22 | RESOLVED - Noted. |